Tisch's career included various Medicaid healthcare leadership roles over the past 30 years. She most recently retired in May, 2020 after 15 years with Anthem, Inc. With Anthem, her experience included roles such as Regional Vice President-West Region Medicaid Operations, CEO of Amerigroup-TX Medicaid, COO Amerigroup Medicaid for Georgia/Illinois and Vice President of Provider Solutions. Prior to Anthem, Tisch was in Medicaid/Medicare leadership roles with Aetna (TX) and United Healthcare (IL). Tisch and her son, Caleb, moved to Traverse City in September 2018 when Caleb started Kindergarten at The Pathfinder School.